By Lisa Maiers

When Choosing College Becomes a Statement About Who You Are

For decades, colleges and universities have demonstrated and communicated their value through career opportunities, lifetime earnings, personal growth and other general benefits of a college degree. But as economic, political and cultural attitudes shift, these traditional value propositions are facing increasing scrutiny.

According to a 2026 Gallup survey, just 38% of Americans express confidence in higher education, down from 57% in 2015. And only 12% believe four-year colleges and universities are doing a good or excellent job providing an affordable education, according to separate Gallup-Lumina research.

As prospective students and their families question the financial investment, practicality and long-term relevance of a four-year degree, political and cultural narratives are creating additional barriers to trust.

Prospective students aren’t just evaluating what an institution can offer. They’re also considering what choosing that institution says about them. 

The changing meaning of college

At KW2, we’ve been exploring three interconnected forces reshaping perceptions of higher education: practical, political and cultural.

The practical questions are familiar. Is college worth the money? Could I learn these skills on the job? Will my degree remain relevant as the workforce changes?

But political and cultural considerations are adding new layers to the decision. Is college for people like me? Does it reflect my values? Will attending college change how others in my community see me?

As reported in Forbes, 34% of surveyed students ruled out colleges because of state politics, up from 24% in 2023. The findings illustrate how perceptions beyond an institution’s academic offerings can influence which colleges students consider in the first place. 

For some audiences, the question is no longer simply whether college is worthwhile. It’s whether pursuing that education feels at odds with their identity, community or beliefs.  

When value isn’t enough to build trust 

Traditional four-year institutions face a particularly difficult challenge because the practicality of their core offering, a liberal arts education, is increasingly being questioned.

The 2026 Gallup-Lumina survey found that only 32% of Americans rated four-year institutions positively for preparing students for the workforce, compared with 50% who gave them positive marks for providing a quality education. That gap suggests institutions may be struggling to connect perceptions of academic quality with practical outcomes.

Traditional messages about personal transformation, professional ambition and lifetime earnings may resonate with students who already believe in the value of a degree. But they may do little to persuade those who view college as financially risky, culturally disconnected or unnecessary for success.

And when perceptions are rooted in deeply held beliefs and identity, facts and benefits alone are unlikely to change minds. 

Rethinking how institutions demonstrate value

Building trust requires colleges and universities to look beyond traditional recruitment strategies and consider how institutional decisions, community relationships and communications influence perceptions.

A few important shifts can help institutions strengthen trust and relevance:

  • Understand audiences beyond demographics. Explore the values, experiences and beliefs shaping perceptions of higher education, including among prospective students who may never enter the traditional recruitment pipeline. 
  • Connect education to existing identities and aspirations. Demonstrate how a degree can build on students' strengths, support their communities and expand opportunities without suggesting they need to become someone different. 
  • Use trusted, unexpected voices to demonstrate value. Authentic student and alumni experiences, employer relationships and community partnerships can make the benefits of education more credible and personally relevant. 
  • Rethink how success is defined. Move beyond traditional measures of career advancement and personal transformation to demonstrate how a four-year education supports different ambitions, lifestyles and community priorities. Help prospective students see how college fits into the future they envision for themselves.

These approaches draw on principles of anti-stigma communications, which recognize that reducing deeply held negative perceptions requires more than presenting facts. It requires understanding the audience, avoiding judgment and building authentic relationships over time. 

Building trust before promoting value 

The growing skepticism surrounding four-year education can't be resolved through a single campaign or a stronger return-on-investment message.

Colleges and universities must recognize that prospective students are evaluating more than programs, costs and career outcomes. They're also weighing how attending college aligns with their values, identities and relationships with the people around them.

For institutional leaders, this means making trust a priority across the student experience, community engagement and institutional communications…not simply an enrollment marketing objective.

The challenge isn't just convincing prospective students that a four-year degree is worth pursuing. It's helping them see that pursuing one doesn't require them to compromise who they are.

And, that starts with listening before leading.